Is using AI cheating?
Your 8th grader pastes the essay prompt into ChatGPT, reads what it produces, and turns it in with minor edits.
Yes — but not for the reason people think. Cheating isn't about using a tool. It's about skipping the learning. The tool is here to stay. The skill of thinking and writing is still the point.
The rule that actually works: "Did you try first?" Kid does the hard part themselves, then uses AI to refine, check, or explain — that's a tutor. Kid skips the thinking and asks AI for the answer — that's cheating, and more importantly, it's theft from their own future self.
What to say if they push back: "I'm not mad about AI. I'm serious about you learning the thing. Using AI after the work is done to polish is fine. Using it instead of the work is what we're not doing."